Accounts Disagree on Lincoln’s Famous Wrestling Match

The Untold Story

Accounts of Lincoln’s famous wrestling match disagree.

One popular version says Lincoln threw Jack Armstrong.

The story places the match in New Salem, where Lincoln became known for his strength.

One version ends with a draw.

A wrestling historian says Lincoln got the better of it. Which account do you believe?

The match’s ending is still disputed, even in later retellings. Follow for more history debates.

Historical Discussion

Some accounts say Lincoln won; others say the match ended in a draw. Which version do you believe?

What are your thoughts on this event? Share your perspective in the discussion or follow Echoes of History Uncut for daily forgotten archives.

What the Record Shows

7 sourced claims in this story, resting on 10 sources. Numbers link to the bibliography below.

• Accounts disagree about the outcome of Lincoln’s match with Jack Armstrong - sources: 6, 12
• One account says Lincoln threw Jack Armstrong - sources: 6, 1, 11
• A popular story describes Abraham Lincoln wrestling Jack Armstrong in New Salem - sources: 3, 2, 7, 6
• Lincoln was known for physical strength and wrestling ability - sources: 1, 6, 3
• One historical account says the Lincoln-Armstrong bout ended in a draw - sources: 13, 10, 2
• Wrestling historian Mike Chapman says Abraham Lincoln got the better of the contest - sources: 14, 6
• Historical accounts and later retellings disagree about the outcome of the Lincoln-Armstrong match - sources: 6, 12, 13, 14

Verified Archival Sources & Bibliography

Every claim in this account has been fact-checked against primary archives and scholarly repositories:

1. National Wrestling Hall of Fame: Abraham Lincoln (primary)
2. Papers of Abraham Lincoln: John (Jack) Armstrong (primary)
3. Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum: Lincoln Before Politics (primary)
4. Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum: People v. Armstrong (primary)
5. National Park Service: Lincoln’s New Salem 1830–1837 (primary)
6. History.com: Abraham Lincoln Excelled in Wrestling (news)
7. Illinois State Archives: Abraham Lincoln in Illinois (primary)
8. Library of Congress: Abraham Lincoln Papers, interview notes (primary)
9. U.S. Government Publishing Office: Abraham Lincoln, A Legacy of Freedom (primary)
10. University of Illinois: Lincoln in Photographs (book)
11. University of Illinois: Lincoln and Historic Illinois (book)
12. Springfield Journal-Register: Rematch with the Past (news)
13. WWE interview with Lincoln scholar Ronald C. White Jr. (news)
14. WIN Magazine: Dispelling the Myths About Lincoln’s Wrestling Days (news)

Recommended Archival Reading & Audiobooks

For those seeking deeper historical immersion into this account:

• Audible 30-Day Free Trial (Includes 1-2 free historical audiobooks of your choice)

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Echoes of History earns from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.